"Truth is disputable, not taste. What exists in the nature of things is the standard of our judgement; what each man feels within himself is the standard of sentiment"
Quote meaning
The core idea here is pretty fascinating if you think about it. It's basically saying that you can argue about what's true all day long, but taste? That's personal. Truth is something we can debate because it’s based on facts or evidence. But taste, on the other hand, is subjective—totally up to the individual.
So, let's put this into a bit of context. This idea, which comes from the 18th century, reflects a time when people were really diving into exploring human perception and understanding. Philosophers like David Hume were trying to figure out what makes something true versus what makes something beautiful or good. They were saying, “Hey, we can use logic and science to determine facts, but when it comes to our feelings or preferences, that's a whole different ball game.”
Now, let's make this more concrete with a real-life example. Imagine a group of friends discussing their favorite movies. One person might argue that "The Godfather" is the greatest movie of all time because of its storytelling and acting. They could bring up facts about its accolades, box office numbers, and critical acclaim. But then another friend might say, “Well, I don’t like it. I prefer science fiction, like 'Blade Runner'.” Here, they’re expressing a personal taste.
You see, you can dispute the merits of "The Godfather" based on its achievements—those are facts. But you can’t argue against someone’s taste for sci-fi over crime dramas. That’s totally subjective, rooted in what they feel inside.
So how do you apply this wisdom to your own life? It's simple but profound: Recognize the difference between debates worth having and personal preferences worth respecting. When you’re discussing something with friends, coworkers, or family, identify whether you’re dealing with a fact (something disputable) or a feeling (something subjective). If it’s the latter, respect their sentiment even if it’s not your cup of tea.
Imagine this scenario: You’re at a holiday dinner and someone starts talking about their favorite holiday tradition. Maybe they love baking cookies because it reminds them of their childhood. Someone else might prefer decorating the tree because it’s a family activity. Instead of debating which tradition is better, appreciate that each tradition holds a special place for each person. It’s not about finding the “right” tradition—it’s about valuing everyone’s individual experiences.
In our daily interactions, this wisdom helps us navigate conversations more smoothly. Next time someone shares their favorite book, music, or even food, remember: it’s their sentiment. You don’t have to agree, but you can appreciate that it's something meaningful to them.
Talking to a friend at a coffee shop, you might say, “You know, I never really got into jazz, but I get that it speaks to you.” And that’s it. Simple, respectful, and understanding. Life’s too short to argue over personal tastes. Just savor the diversity of human experience and let everyone have their own flavor.
So, let's put this into a bit of context. This idea, which comes from the 18th century, reflects a time when people were really diving into exploring human perception and understanding. Philosophers like David Hume were trying to figure out what makes something true versus what makes something beautiful or good. They were saying, “Hey, we can use logic and science to determine facts, but when it comes to our feelings or preferences, that's a whole different ball game.”
Now, let's make this more concrete with a real-life example. Imagine a group of friends discussing their favorite movies. One person might argue that "The Godfather" is the greatest movie of all time because of its storytelling and acting. They could bring up facts about its accolades, box office numbers, and critical acclaim. But then another friend might say, “Well, I don’t like it. I prefer science fiction, like 'Blade Runner'.” Here, they’re expressing a personal taste.
You see, you can dispute the merits of "The Godfather" based on its achievements—those are facts. But you can’t argue against someone’s taste for sci-fi over crime dramas. That’s totally subjective, rooted in what they feel inside.
So how do you apply this wisdom to your own life? It's simple but profound: Recognize the difference between debates worth having and personal preferences worth respecting. When you’re discussing something with friends, coworkers, or family, identify whether you’re dealing with a fact (something disputable) or a feeling (something subjective). If it’s the latter, respect their sentiment even if it’s not your cup of tea.
Imagine this scenario: You’re at a holiday dinner and someone starts talking about their favorite holiday tradition. Maybe they love baking cookies because it reminds them of their childhood. Someone else might prefer decorating the tree because it’s a family activity. Instead of debating which tradition is better, appreciate that each tradition holds a special place for each person. It’s not about finding the “right” tradition—it’s about valuing everyone’s individual experiences.
In our daily interactions, this wisdom helps us navigate conversations more smoothly. Next time someone shares their favorite book, music, or even food, remember: it’s their sentiment. You don’t have to agree, but you can appreciate that it's something meaningful to them.
Talking to a friend at a coffee shop, you might say, “You know, I never really got into jazz, but I get that it speaks to you.” And that’s it. Simple, respectful, and understanding. Life’s too short to argue over personal tastes. Just savor the diversity of human experience and let everyone have their own flavor.
Related tags
Dispute Feelings Individuality Judgement Nature Perception Sentiment Subjectivity Taste Truth
MORE QUOTES BY David Hume
FEATURED QUOTES