"No es la conciencia de los hombres la que determina su ser, sino su ser social el que determina su conciencia."
Quote meaning
This quote is really getting at the idea that our thoughts, beliefs, and how we see the world are shaped by the society and environment we live in, rather than the other way around. Imagine you’re sitting in a coffee shop with a friend, chatting about how people think and why they think the way they do. You might say, “Hey, look around. The way people dress, what they talk about, even what they order—it’s all influenced by the culture and the society they’re part of.” That’s exactly what this quote is saying: our consciousness—our awareness and thoughts—are molded by our social existence.
Historically speaking, this idea comes from Karl Marx, a philosopher from the 19th century. He believed that the economic and social structures of a society heavily influence the way people think. Marx was living in a time when industrialization was changing the world dramatically. People were moving from farms to factories, and this shift was transforming how they saw themselves and their potential in life. Marx argued that if you want to understand why people think the way they do, you need to look at their material and social conditions—their work, their community, their economic status.
Now, let’s consider a vivid real-life example. Think about a young woman growing up in a wealthy family in a developed country. She has access to excellent education, healthcare, and numerous opportunities. Her social being—her environment and circumstances—fosters a certain consciousness. She likely believes in the possibility of achieving her dreams, the value of hard work, and the idea that her individual actions can have a significant impact. Contrast this with another young woman growing up in a war-torn region with limited access to basic necessities. Her social being is completely different, and so her consciousness is shaped by survival, resilience, and perhaps a deep understanding of the fragility of life.
So, how can you apply this wisdom in your own life? Start by being aware of the influences around you. Think about how your job, your community, your family, and your country shape your thoughts and beliefs. Question them. Are there aspects of your social being that limit your perspective? Maybe you're in a job that stifles your creativity, or in a social circle that values certain things that you’ve never questioned. By recognizing these influences, you can begin to shift your consciousness—choosing to expose yourself to new ideas, different people, and various experiences.
Here’s a relatable scenario: Imagine you’re working in a corporate job that pays well but doesn’t fulfill you. You start to think, “Is this all there is?” This feeling is a product of your social being. Your job, your colleagues, and the company culture all shape how you see the world. But what if you decided to travel, volunteer, or take up a new hobby? These new experiences could dramatically alter your consciousness, leading you to new insights and perhaps a completely different path in life.
So, the next time you find yourself questioning why you think a certain way or why certain beliefs seem so ingrained, remember—it’s not just you. It’s the world around you shaping those thoughts. And the exciting part? You have the power to change your social being and, in turn, transform your consciousness.
Historically speaking, this idea comes from Karl Marx, a philosopher from the 19th century. He believed that the economic and social structures of a society heavily influence the way people think. Marx was living in a time when industrialization was changing the world dramatically. People were moving from farms to factories, and this shift was transforming how they saw themselves and their potential in life. Marx argued that if you want to understand why people think the way they do, you need to look at their material and social conditions—their work, their community, their economic status.
Now, let’s consider a vivid real-life example. Think about a young woman growing up in a wealthy family in a developed country. She has access to excellent education, healthcare, and numerous opportunities. Her social being—her environment and circumstances—fosters a certain consciousness. She likely believes in the possibility of achieving her dreams, the value of hard work, and the idea that her individual actions can have a significant impact. Contrast this with another young woman growing up in a war-torn region with limited access to basic necessities. Her social being is completely different, and so her consciousness is shaped by survival, resilience, and perhaps a deep understanding of the fragility of life.
So, how can you apply this wisdom in your own life? Start by being aware of the influences around you. Think about how your job, your community, your family, and your country shape your thoughts and beliefs. Question them. Are there aspects of your social being that limit your perspective? Maybe you're in a job that stifles your creativity, or in a social circle that values certain things that you’ve never questioned. By recognizing these influences, you can begin to shift your consciousness—choosing to expose yourself to new ideas, different people, and various experiences.
Here’s a relatable scenario: Imagine you’re working in a corporate job that pays well but doesn’t fulfill you. You start to think, “Is this all there is?” This feeling is a product of your social being. Your job, your colleagues, and the company culture all shape how you see the world. But what if you decided to travel, volunteer, or take up a new hobby? These new experiences could dramatically alter your consciousness, leading you to new insights and perhaps a completely different path in life.
So, the next time you find yourself questioning why you think a certain way or why certain beliefs seem so ingrained, remember—it’s not just you. It’s the world around you shaping those thoughts. And the exciting part? You have the power to change your social being and, in turn, transform your consciousness.
MORE QUOTES BY Karl Marx
FEATURED QUOTES