Get Started
Home Authors Tags

"Je ne crois pas qu'il y ait une 'volonté populaire' puissante et mystérieuse, une volonté commune qui s'exprime inexorablement malgré la répression."

Mario Vargas Llosa
Mario Vargas Llosa Novelist
Translations
🇺🇸 English 🇨🇳 中文 🇪🇸 Español 🇪🇬 العربية 🇫🇷 Français 🇮🇷 فارسی 🇯🇵 日本語
Quote meaning
Alright, let’s dive into this. The essence of the quote is that the idea of a collective, almost magical "popular will" isn’t something the speaker buys into. They’re skeptical about this notion that there's some kind of unstoppable force representing the true desires of the masses, which can't be suppressed no matter how hard anyone tries.

Historically, this kind of statement might come from someone who has seen the harsh realities of political movements and revolutions. Think about the times when people talk about the "will of the people" as if it’s some kind of unerring, collective consciousness. This kind of rhetoric is often used in political speeches or revolutionary movements to galvanize support, suggesting that the people, as a whole, have a unified and powerful voice that must be obeyed or respected. However, this speaker seems to be grounding their perspective in reality, recognizing that such a concept is more myth than fact.

Imagine this scenario: In a small town, there's a controversial proposal to build a huge shopping mall. The town is split. Some people want the jobs and convenience it’ll bring, while others fear it'll destroy local businesses and change the town’s character. If someone were to say, "The will of the people will prevail," they’re assuming there’s a clear, unified desire among the townsfolk. But in reality, the situation is much more muddled. People’s opinions are varied and complex, and the idea of a single, powerful will of the people doesn’t really hold water.

So, how do you use this insight in your own life? When you hear about the "will of the people," take it with a grain of salt. Recognize that people's desires and opinions are often fragmented. Be cautious about movements or leaders who claim to know what everyone wants or who speak about the popular will as if it's monolithic and unstoppable. Ask questions, dig deeper, and understand that consensus is rare and difficult to achieve.

Here’s a relatable story to bring this home. Imagine you’re part of a local sports club. There’s a debate about whether to spend the club’s funds on renovating the gym or building new tennis courts. The committee leader insists that "everyone wants the tennis courts," but you’ve heard plenty of people who prefer the gym renovation. If you accept the idea of a popular will uncritically, you might think you’re in the minority and stay quiet. But knowing that the idea of a unified popular will is often oversimplified, you speak up. You gather others who share your view and present a balanced case. In the end, the club holds a vote, and it turns out the gym renovation wins. By questioning the notion of a singular popular will, you’ve helped ensure a more democratic and fair decision-making process.

So next time you hear about the "will of the people," remember that real-life is messy and opinions are diverse. There’s no mystical force guiding these decisions—just individuals with their own perspectives and voices. And it’s important to make sure all those voices get heard.
Related tags
Freedom of thought Individualism Personal beliefs Political philosophy Political theory Repression Skepticism
MORE QUOTES BY Mario Vargas Llosa
FEATURED QUOTES
Surprise me with another quote
Instagram Icon Facebook Icon X Icon Threads Icon