"دلیل اساسی شکست استدلال عقل‌گرایان این است که لذتی که فرض می‌کند وجود ندارد"

The main point here is that the rationalist argument assumes there’s a certain kind of pleasure that just isn’t real. Rationalists often believe that people make decisions based on logical and calculated thinking, expecting to derive pleasure from these choices. But, in reality, the pleasure they’re counting on doesn't always show up.

Let’s take a trip back in time for some context. Rationalism, as a philosophy, has roots in the Enlightenment when thinkers like Descartes and Spinoza emphasized reason as the path to knowledge. The idea was that human beings could logically figure out what’s best for them and then act accordingly to achieve happiness. Sounds neat, right? But life isn’t always that straightforward. The problem is, our emotions and irrational desires often play a bigger role than pure logic.

Imagine you’re at a fancy bakery eyeing a luscious chocolate cake. Rationally, you know the cake has too many calories and could ruin your diet. But you buy it anyway because the thought of savoring that rich, creamy slice is irresistible. Rationally, indulging might not make sense, but the imagined pleasure—that momentary bliss—is what drives you. Now, think about when the cake is gone. You might feel a pang of regret or guilt. The pleasure you thought you’d get? It wasn't as fulfilling as you expected.

Here’s a more concrete example. Let’s talk about buying a new car. You do all the research, comparing safety features, fuel efficiency, and cost. Rationally, you decide on a reliable, sensible vehicle. But then, you see a sleek, red sports car and you can’t stop thinking about how cool you’d look driving it. Despite knowing it’s impractical and expensive, you buy it. Initially, you feel ecstatic. But after a few months, when the excitement wears off and you’re stuck with high payments and maintenance costs, the pleasure you anticipated has vanished. The rationalist argument failed because it assumed a straightforward path to pleasure that just didn’t pan out.

So how can you apply this wisdom? First, be aware of your emotional triggers and how they impact your decisions. When faced with a choice, pause and ask yourself if the pleasure you’re expecting is real or just a fleeting illusion. Try to balance logical thinking with an understanding of your emotional needs. Recognize that sometimes, the pleasure you’re chasing might not be as satisfying as you think.

Picture this scenario. You’re offered a high-paying job in a city across the country. Rationally, it’s a no-brainer. More money, better prospects. But moving means leaving behind friends, family, and a community you love. You imagine all the things you could buy with that extra income, but will they really make up for the loss of your support network and familiar surroundings? Maybe not. The supposed pleasure of more money might not outweigh the very real happiness of staying close to loved ones.

In a nutshell, don’t get duped by the allure of a pleasure that doesn’t exist. Life’s too complex and our minds too tricky. Listen to your heart, not just your head, and you’ll find a balance that leads to true contentment.