Get Started
Home Authors Tags

"自由意志与科学决定论之间的矛盾只是种错觉"

Yuval Noah Harari
Yuval Noah Harari Historian and Author
Translations
🇺🇸 English 🇨🇳 中文 🇪🇸 Español 🇪🇬 العربية 🇫🇷 Français 🇮🇷 فارسی 🇯🇵 日本語
Quote meaning
The main idea here is that the apparent conflict between the concept of free will and the notion that our actions are determined by scientific laws is, in fact, not a real conflict. It's more like a misunderstanding—like when you think you left your keys in your bag but find them in your pocket instead. There's no fundamental clash between the two ideas; they can coexist.

Let's take a step back and consider the historical context. The debate between free will and determinism has been around for centuries. Philosophers like Aristotle and Epicurus pondered it, and it took a scientific turn with the advent of Newtonian physics. The idea that every action is a result of previous states and laws made people wonder if everything, including human behavior, is predetermined. Fast forward to the 20th century, and quantum mechanics threw some wrenches into the mix, suggesting that at a fundamental level, randomness plays a role too.

Now, let's bring this to life with a real-world example. Think about a chess game. When you’re playing, you make decisions based on a combination of your strategy (free will) and the rules of the game (determinism). You decide to move your bishop, but that move is constrained by the rules of chess. Here's the kicker: you still have free will within those constraints. You can choose any legal move, but you can’t just move pieces randomly or against the rules. It’s the same with life. We make choices, but those choices are influenced by a myriad of factors—our upbringing, our current situation, our knowledge.

So, what’s the practical takeaway? Don’t get hung up on whether your choices are truly free or entirely predetermined. Focus on making the best decisions you can within your circumstances. Think about it this way: if you find yourself at a crossroads in life—maybe deciding on a career path or whether to move to a new city—realize that while many factors (education, job market, personal interests) shape your options, the final decision is yours. Embrace that freedom.

Imagine you’re talking to your friend over coffee. They’re stuck, feeling like every choice is out of their hands—like life is just happening to them. You can share a story to illustrate this idea. Picture a gardener working in their garden. They didn’t choose the soil quality, the initial state of the plants, or the weather. But they can choose how to tend to the garden—what plants to grow, how much to water them, how to arrange them. Despite the given conditions, the gardener’s actions significantly shape the outcome. Life’s kind of like that garden. You work with the conditions you're given, but you have the agency to make it flourish in your own way.

So next time you're feeling that existential dread creep in, remember you're like that gardener. Sure, there are things you can't control—but there's a whole lot you can. Make the most of those decisions, and don't sweat the larger philosophical debate too much. You’ve got more power than you think.
Related tags
Contradiction Existentialism Free will Human behavior Illusion Metaphysics Mind Philosophy Psychology
MORE QUOTES BY Yuval Noah Harari
FEATURED QUOTES
Surprise me with another quote
Instagram Icon Facebook Icon X Icon Threads Icon